When the story of a movie revolves around a mother's
relentless struggle to find her children, it must be worth it. Ashima Chibber's
Mrs Chatterjee Vs Norway actress Rani Mukerji as Debika Chatterjee who is
separated from her two children by Norway's child protection program under the
pretext of foster care better. Based on a real incident that happened in 2011
and caused a diplomatic dispute between India and Norway, Ms. Chatterjee Vs
Norway boasts of great writing and performance and still looks great. It often
tears you apart and makes you think about ideas.
The incident shocked India as many followed the tragic case
of Indian couple Sagarika and Anurup Bhattacharya in Barnevernet, Norway's
child protection agency who abducted their children due to abusive parents. The
couple was accused of making their children sleep in their beds, feeding them
with their hands and applying kohl. The father was accused of not helping his
wife with housework and said the mother was unreasonable. The Indian media
reported the news very heartbreakingly, with many pointing to the huge cultural
differences between the two countries in their views on raising children.
Since many people know Ms. Chatterjee's story against
Norway, it was more of a challenge to make the film appeal to the audience.
Written by Chibber with Rahul Handa and Sameer Satija, the film is set in a
mood, which is one of despair, uncertainty and anxiety. Debika and her husband
Anirudh (Anirban Bhattacharya) run from post to post to collect their children
from the Norwegian authorities but roadblocks hit one by one. It doesn't help that
there are already cracks in their relationship. Anirudh is portrayed as an
ambitious man, who does not want to offend or challenge the Norwegian
government to gain citizenship in the country. He is also a virgin who does not
believe that he helps his wife around the house at times and brings her along
mainly because of his desire to succeed at work.
Debika, meanwhile, takes care of the family and two
children. Her son, who the authorities suspect, has autism and she is still
feeding her five-month-old daughter. The separation aggravated him and he ended
up behaving badly during several court hearings, leading the Norwegian
authorities to believe the declaration of his mental insanity and thus
restricting his access to children it will meet.
Authors should be given credit for what they have achieved.
They carry a good feeling that you will eventually sympathize with his mother
and her pain and separation from her children. Chibber also includes Bengali
wells. The dialogue, especially between Mukerji and Bhattacharya, is similar to
how Bengali couples talk or argue.
The feeling is there. At one point, the Rani is heard
arguing about how to use a fork to serve the child macher jhol-bhaat (fish and
rice curry) - a dish that is a staple in every Bengali household. This food is
fed to the children, or the family eats, and the reaction of the actors in the
middle of the conflict is very true to the Bengali family. In this way the
changing scene creates the right place.
What is inconsistent is Rani Mukerji's Hindi, which she
deliberately tries to speak badly because of her character's background. It is
clear that it separates the actor because there are times when he forgets his
character and speaks Hindi effortlessly but he reverts to the language form and
-no need.
Rani Mukerji also plays her role as Debika. Yes, she is an
angry mother in some scenes so powerful that Rani can portray her character's
pain well, but she often goes the emotional route in melodrama. But while we
want to feel deeply about his character and the pain he is going through, we
end up squirming at his nonsensical behavior. Rani is still holding her own
with the drama that rests on her shoulders.
The rest of the actors are great. Famous Bengali actor
Anirban Bhattacharya makes his Bollywood debut in this film as the cold,
passive and self-centered Mr. Chatterjee who is just thinking about getting
citizenship in Norway. Bhattacharya is famous for all his performances in
various Bengali movies and in Mrs. Chatterjee Vs Norway he is so special in
Anirudh's role that you don't like him.
Another successful actor is Jim Sarbh as the Norwegian
lawyer Daniel Singh Ciupek - a man who is mistreated as being unsympathetic to
Chatterjees at first and conniving. Sarbh delivers an unflinching and confident
performance. The courtroom scene between him and actor Balaji Gauri, who plays
lawyer Rani, is the best scene in the film, which is played by actors who well,
making them the best time.
The casting is correct. Many famous Bengali actors are
doing supporting roles in the movie easily. There are Barun Chanda, Bodhisatva
Majumdar, Mithu Chakraborty and Saswati Guhathakurta who are doing their best.
Neena Gupta has a cameo - as a politician who impersonates the late Sushma
Swaraj - which plays a critical role in the case.
The film has a nonsensical plot. The first episode, when
Anirban and Rani are trying to get their children back, where Rani's pain is
spot on, seems shocking after some time. You want to feel their emotions, but
because of the melodrama and the fact that Rani is playing to the gallery, that
doesn't translate well to the audience. The pace picks up in the second half,
especially in the last hour as the story goes to India. Sarbh shows great
acting ability in courtroom drama and shines there.
Ultimately Mrs. Chatterjee Vs Norway is uneven. But it is
the story that is the biggest triumph in this heartbreaking story. Of course,
there is melodrama, but the central story of the film is such that it makes you
feel good. After all, a mother's love for her children is known, and that
always makes for an interesting story.